How to Make Him Want More After a One Night Stand: 35 Ways to Win Him Over

You had a one night stand, and now you want to see him again. How can you make that happen? Follow these tips and you might win him over.

Let’s talk about one night stands, a familiar plot twist in our modern dating tales. You know the drill: a spark, an unforgettable night, and then it’s over, almost as quickly as it started. But wait, what if you find yourself wanting a bit more? What if you’re curious about turning that single encounter into something a bit more…lasting? In the world of ‘hit it and quit it,’ we’re diving into the less talked about narrative – how to make him want more after a one night stand.

Let’s get into the nitty-gritty of turning that one wild night into a potential repeat performance. [Read: Kinky sex positions for a wild night every day of the week]

Questions Guys Ask After a One-Night Stand

Below are some of the questions guys ask themselves when it comes to deciding if they want their one night stand to be something more.

1. Was the Sex Good?

This is the first point because it is an important one. Guys like sex, and if it’s good, they tend to want to keep doing it. If it’s not so good, they’re less inclined to go back–unless they’re desperate.

Having sex in the morning, especially if you initiate it, is always a winner. Men are almost universally horny in the morning, and you jumping on him will most definitely please him.

Depending on how much alcohol was consumed, he might not remember much about last night, so this is the opportunity to do it over and build some good memories that won’t be forgotten! [Read: 26 Woman on top sex moves to be good on top and make him orgasm hard]

Sex isn’t the only way to a man’s heart, but it is a sure-fire way to capture his attention and make him want to stick around for a while to see what happens.

2. Was She Interesting Outside of the Bedroom?

This is the second most important thing. Did you have a good time together when you weren’t having sex?

Keep things lighthearted, and have a laugh. Find things that you bond over, and it will take on a “more than just sex” feeling. [Read: 18 Fun secrets to be the life of the party and be noticed and loved by everyone]

This doesn’t mean trying to be one of the guys *unless that’s your normal personality* but some teasing and flirting, along with normal friendly conversation, will usually build a bit of a bond.

Contrary to popular belief, men don’t just want to have sex. They also want to be around people that they like and enjoy spending time with. Some will have sex, leave, and be fairly happy with that, but most prefer a little bit more.

Obviously, this isn’t something you can force. People either get along, or they don’t, but make an effort to get to know each other. [Read: 10 reasons guys run away after sleeping with you]

Many girls ask way too many questions when doing this, and it’s quite overbearing, so try to let conversation flow naturally and expand upon topics of interest, rather than insisting on an interview-style conversation.

3. Was She Cooperative?

If she is not cooperative in the morning, it will leave a sour taste. Even if the sex was good and we had a laugh, if she is not respectful of the guy’s time, he will lose interest very quickly.

This is especially relevant if he has to leave for work. As the saying goes, “Never outstay your welcome.” [Read: 62 Flirty topics and things to talk about with a guy to keep him interested]

Don’t sulk about it, and if you’re at his place, don’t hold him up. Of course, you should expect the same in return if you have to get somewhere. Even helping tidy up a bit is a gesture that goes a long way.

Sometimes, women will take his urgency to get moving as an escape plan to get away and become upset. Of course, sometimes that is the case… but a lot of the time, he genuinely has to be somewhere and needs to move quickly.

Even if you think it is an excuse to get out quickly, being uncooperative is definitely not going to make him like you more. Instead, he’ll immediately brand you as clingy. [Read: 10 worst people to have a one night stand with]

4. Did She Treat Me Well?

This is one of the big things that differentiates “someone I had sex with one time” and “someone I like.” Guys want to be treated well. They like it when you help out, follow the rules if you’re at his place, or look after him if he is at yours.

Little things like helping him tidy the room and making sure you don’t leave hair all over the bathroom goes a long way with guys. Likewise, if he is at your place, fetching him a drink and offering breakfast will go a long way.

Making sure he has directions to get home is a nice gesture-you would want at least the same if you were at his place, wouldn’t you? [Read: 9 almost-relationships of the modern dating world]

5. Does She Want What I Want?

You need to be on the same page for where “this” is going, whatever “this” is. Often, when women are keen to see a guy again, they come across as clingy or way too forward. This will scare a guy away in a snap.

You should show you are interested through your actions, and make sure that you swap contact details *of course*. However, don’t force him to pin down a date or ask when you will see each other again.

Men need a bit of space sometimes, and he will be in touch to arrange meeting again if he likes you. [Read: 41 Things girls do that guys live and make them crazy for you]

If you come across as too needy, or like you are looking for a boyfriend when he isn’t ready, you stand a good chance of scaring him away. Let things develop naturally, and consider what “this” is when you know each other a little better.

Likewise, if you just want a casual relationship, don’t be too cold. He will likely misread this and think you are not interested.

You can be affectionate in a casual way to ensure that he knows you like him but aren’t asking for too much, too soon. [Read: Casual sex – how to find the hookup of your dreams]

The perfect middle ground is to just do what feels right, and let things play out how they will.

6. Did She Show Genuine Interest in Me?

Men often wonder if their partner was truly interested in them or just in the moment. This goes beyond the physical; it’s about feeling valued and seen as an individual.

When a woman shows genuine curiosity about a man’s life, his passions, and his thoughts, it can create a connection that lasts beyond the one night stand. [Read: 99 Weird, funny questions to ask a guy to show off your fun and playful side]

This is a key factor in how to make him want more after a one night stand, as it taps into the need for emotional connection and being more than just a physical partner.

7. Was There a Spark Beyond Physical Attraction?

Physical attraction might spark a one night stand, but men also ponder the emotional or intellectual chemistry they felt. Did the conversation flow effortlessly? Was there laughter and shared understanding?

These elements can be crucial in making him want more after a one night stand, as they indicate a deeper compatibility that might pique his interest in exploring the relationship further. [Read: How to emotionally connect with a man and find a deeper connection]

8. Did She Leave a Lasting Impression?

Men often reflect on whether the woman left a unique and lasting impression on them. This could be through her sense of humor, intelligence, kindness, or even the way she handled herself with confidence.

A lasting impression is a significant factor in making him want more after a one night stand, as it sets her apart from others and ignites a desire to get to know her better.

9. How Did She Handle the Morning After?

The way the morning is navigated can greatly influence a man’s perception. Was she comfortable and easygoing, or was there awkwardness and haste? [Read: How to be cool – what it really means and 18 hacks to look way cooler]

A positive, relaxed morning interaction can be a critical element in how to make him want more after a one night stand. It’s about leaving on a high note, making the overall experience memorable and enjoyable.

10. Is There Potential for Compatibility?

Finally, men consider the potential for compatibility. This isn’t just about shared interests or backgrounds; it’s about aligning in values, life goals, and how they view relationships.

Understanding this can be crucial in how to make him want more after a one night stand. [Read: 40 Core values in a relationship, why they matter, and secrets to align them]

If a man senses that there’s a foundation for compatibility, it might encourage him to pursue something more meaningful beyond the initial encounter.

Tips on How to Make Him Want More

Okay, let’s get real: just because it started as a one night stand doesn’t mean it’s a hopeless case for anything more. Sure, it might have begun with no strings attached, but who says you can’t tie a knot if it feels right?

Below are some psychology-backed tips to nudge things in a direction where ‘just for tonight’ might just turn into ‘how about another night?’ [Read: 23 Secrets to tell a guy you like him over text, BIG mistakes and must-knows]

1. Engage in Meaningful Conversation

Okay, just because it’s a one night stand doesn’t mean it’s a hopeless case. Start by engaging in meaningful conversations. Show genuine interest in his life, his thoughts, and feelings.

This isn’t just small talk; it’s about diving a bit deeper. Psychologically, when someone feels heard and understood, it creates a bond beyond the physical, making him more likely to want to see you again.

2. Showcase Your Unique Personality

Be yourself – unapologetically. Share your interests, quirks, and passions. Psychological studies suggest that authenticity is attractive; it fosters trust and connection. [Read: 33 Secrets to be true to yourself and 15 signs you need to unfake your life]

This authenticity can be a game-changer in how to make him want more after a one night stand, as it sets you apart from others and piques his curiosity about you.

3. Balance Interest with Independence

Show you’re interested but also maintain your own independence and sense of self. According to relationship psychology, a balance between dependence and independence can be incredibly attractive.

It suggests you’re not just looking for any connection, but the right one. This balance can intrigue him, making him want to explore what more you have to offer. [Read: 24 Ways to be a strong, independent woman all men love and desire]

4. Leave a Positive Lasting Impression

Make your time together memorable. Whether it’s your sense of humor, your kindness, or your intellect, let these shine.

A positive lasting impression aligns with the psychological concept of the ‘halo effect,’ where one good quality positively influences overall perception, making him more inclined to pursue more than just a one night stand.

5. Non-Verbal Cues Matter

Pay attention to your body language. Non-verbal cues like eye contact, smiling, and an open posture can speak volumes. [Read: Body language attraction – 58 male and female signs and how to read and use them]

Psychology tells us that these cues can convey interest and attraction more effectively than words, subtly suggesting that you’re open to more than just a fleeting connection.

6. Follow Up Without Pressure

After the encounter, a casual follow-up message can show interest without putting pressure. The key is to keep it light and breezy.

This aligns with psychological principles of scarcity and mystery, which can increase desire and curiosity, making him think about the potential of more encounters with you. [Read: How to be mysterious and leave everyone smitten and craving for more]

7. Share and Respect Boundaries

Make your boundaries clear and respect his. This mutual respect for personal boundaries is foundational in psychological theories of healthy relationships.

It shows maturity and understanding, traits that are appealing for anyone considering a deeper connection.

8. Show Appreciation for the Little Things

It’s often the small gestures that leave a lasting impression.

When he does something thoughtful, whether it’s a considerate comment or a kind act, acknowledging it shows you’re attentive and appreciative. [Read: 44 Warm ways to say “I appreciate you” and show appreciation without words]

This behavior is reinforced by psychological principles of positive reinforcement, which suggest that behavior followed by positive feedback is more likely to be repeated.

Expressing gratitude for these small gestures can make him feel seen and appreciated, fostering a deeper connection that could make him more interested in pursuing something beyond the one night stand.

9. Cultivate an Air of Mystery

Maintaining a sense of mystery can significantly pique his interest. According to psychological studies, humans are naturally curious creatures, and a little mystery can intensify this curiosity. [Read: 32 Secrets to play hard to get with a guy selectively and leave him smitten]

By not revealing everything about yourself right away, you create an intriguing puzzle for him to solve over time. This doesn’t mean being secretive or deceitful, but rather letting him discover the layers of your personality gradually.

This approach can keep him engaged and curious about what else there is to know about you.

10. Use Humor to Your Advantage

Humor is a powerful tool in forming connections. Shared laughter can create a bond and ease any lingering awkwardness from the initial encounter. [Read: How to be funny – 28 must-know tips to make everyone love your humor]

Psychologically, humor is often associated with intelligence and the ability to view situations from different perspectives.

By showcasing your sense of humor, you’re not only making the time spent together more enjoyable but also demonstrating traits that are attractive in a long-term partner.

11. Display Confidence

Confidence is universally attractive. It’s not about dominating the conversation or being overly assertive, but about exuding a sense of self-assurance and comfort in your own skin. [Read: 55 Secrets and self-love habits to build confidence and realize your worth]

Confidence can enhance your attractiveness, as it is often perceived as a sign of security and self-awareness.

Psychological research supports the idea that confident individuals are often seen as more attractive, so showcasing your self-assurance might increase his interest in seeing where things could go beyond the initial encounter.

12. Engage in Shared Activities

Participating in activities together can strengthen your connection. This could be as simple as a walk in the park, a coffee run, or sharing a hobby. [Read: 65 Couples activities and fun things to do that’ll make you feel closer than ever]

Social psychology suggests that shared experiences can significantly deepen bonds between individuals.

These activities provide opportunities to get to know each other in different contexts and create shared memories, which can be foundational for a more profound relationship.

13. Be Emotionally Available

Emotional availability is key in forming a deeper bond. While it’s important not to overshare or become overly intense too quickly, showing that you’re open to emotional connection can be inviting. [Read: How to be emotionally available 17 ways to open up to love and life]

Being emotionally available means being receptive to both sharing and listening.

This level of emotional engagement can demonstrate your capacity for a deeper relationship, making him more inclined to explore what more you have to offer beyond the physical connection.

14. Respect His Space and Individuality

Respecting his space and individuality is crucial. Everyone values their personal space and autonomy. [Read: How to know when to give someone space – 19 signs they’re sick of you]

By showing that you respect his need for personal space and individuality, you’re demonstrating a key understanding of healthy relationship dynamics. Psychologically, autonomy is a critical component of healthy relationships.

When you show respect for his personal space and individuality, it can make the prospect of spending more time with you more appealing, as it suggests a balanced and healthy dynamic.

15. Foster Emotional Intimacy

Building emotional intimacy is a key step in deepening the connection beyond a one night stand. [Read: 12 Stages of physical intimacy and 18 truths to go from strangers to lovers]

This involves more than just physical closeness; it’s about creating a safe space where both of you feel comfortable sharing thoughts, feelings, and vulnerabilities.

According to psychological theories, emotional intimacy is the foundation of strong, lasting relationships. It involves active listening, empathy, and the mutual sharing of personal experiences and emotions.

By fostering this level of intimacy, you signal that you’re interested in more than just a physical connection. [Read: Sexual intimacy – the meaning, 20 signs you’re losing it, and secrets to grow it]

This approach encourages a deeper form of bonding, which can make him more likely to see the potential for a meaningful relationship.

Establishing emotional intimacy can transform a casual encounter into a connection that both of you might want to explore further.

Common Pitfalls When Trying to Make Him Want More After a One-Night Stand

Sometimes, our best intentions can lead us astray if we’re not careful. Here are some common pitfalls that you might want to steer clear of. [Read: 16 signs to know if it’ll be a one night stand]

Avoiding these missteps can make the difference between kindling a potential flame and extinguishing it before it has a chance to grow.

1. Over-Communication

While staying in touch is important, excessive texting or calling can be overwhelming. It’s crucial to strike a balance.

Over-communication can come off as needy or invasive, potentially pushing him away. Respect his space and allow the connection to develop naturally. [Read: How to stop being needy – why people get clingy and 32 ways to fix it]

2. Setting Unrealistic Expectations

Avoid building up unrealistic expectations about where things might lead. Remember, a one night stand might not always evolve into a deeper relationship.

Setting high expectations can lead to disappointment and may put unnecessary pressure on both of you.

3. Ignoring His Boundaries

Respecting boundaries is key in any interaction. Pay attention to his comfort levels and respect his limits. Disregarding boundaries can be a major turn-off and is often a red flag in any developing relationship. [Read: Why am I codependent? 37 reasons and signs you overstep boundaries in love]

4. Trying Too Hard to Impress

While it’s natural to want to put your best foot forward, trying too hard can come across as inauthentic. Be yourself and let things flow naturally. Authenticity is more attractive than a forced persona.

5. Neglecting Your Own Needs and Boundaries

In the pursuit of making him want more, don’t neglect your own needs and boundaries. A healthy relationship is built on mutual respect and understanding.

Prioritize your own well-being and don’t compromise your values and comfort for the sake of keeping his interest. [Read: Love yourself first – where people go wrong, 36 whys, and how to do this right]

6. Misreading His Intentions

Be careful not to misinterpret politeness or casual interest as a deeper attraction. Pay attention to his actions and words to gauge his level of interest. Misreading intentions can lead to awkward situations and misunderstandings.

7. Jumping to Conclusions About the Relationship

Avoid jumping to conclusions about the status or future of your relationship. Give it time to evolve without forcing labels or commitments too soon. This allows both of you to understand your feelings and intentions more clearly.

8. Forgetting to Enjoy the Moment

Lastly, don’t get so caught up in trying to secure a future with him that you forget to enjoy the present. [Read: 32 Secrets to be present and live in the moment when life is speeding past you]

The early stages of any connection should be fun and exciting. Stay present and enjoy getting to know each other.

9. Overanalyzing Every Interaction

Getting caught up in overanalyzing his every text, call, or lack thereof can create unnecessary stress and may lead to wrong conclusions.

Remember, not every action needs deep interpretation. [Read: 38 Secrets to stop overthinking, what it looks like, signs, and the fastest fixes]

Constant analysis can make the interaction feel more like a strategy game than a developing relationship, potentially leading to anxiety and miscommunication.

10. Losing Your Individuality

In an effort to align more closely with his interests or preferences, there’s a risk of losing your own individuality. It’s important to remain true to yourself and your interests.

A healthy relationship allows both partners to maintain their unique identities. [Read: 14 Spirited steps to be independent in a relationship and love better]

Losing yourself in the process of trying to make him want more is counterproductive and can lead to an unbalanced relationship dynamic.

Not Every Encounter is Destined for a Fairy-Tale Ending

With the tips laid out above, you’ve got a solid foundation on how to make him want more after a one night stand. Remember, there’s no magic formula guaranteed to work every time.

Relationships, much like the people in them, are wonderfully complex and unique. [Read: Dating your one night stand – easy or sleazy?]

Effective communication and understanding each other’s perspectives are key factors that can significantly influence the direction of a new relationship.

Of course, it’s important to acknowledge the reality of modern dating — not every encounter is destined for a fairy-tale ending. [Read: The pros and cons of using dating apps to snag a date]

You might encounter guys who aren’t looking for anything serious, are on their way out of town, or, dare we say, have other commitments they haven’t mentioned.

But remember, understanding how to make him want more after a one night stand is part of this unpredictable journey. It’s all about navigating these experiences with a blend of hope and realism. So don’t let the uncertainties deter you.

[Read: What to do when you run into your ex one night stand]

Embrace the excitement and the unpredictability of relationships. The right connection, under the right circumstances, can surprise you, turning what started as a one night stand can turn into something more meaningful and lasting.